Civil Liberties and Immigration Restriction: Many of us have been warning about the dangers of mass immigration for years, and now the issue is one of the most widely contested issues in politics. Some of those who advocate more restriction, support using measures that most conservatives and libertarians would normally oppose, such as National ID Cards, RICO laws and other tools that may potentially undermine the liberties of American Citizens. Are these necessary for reducing immigration? Is the threat so great, that we must do whatever it takes?

Jim Pinkerton- Contributing editor to American Conservative.and Senior Fellow at the New America Foundation. James Pinkerton worked in the White House under Presidents Ronald Reagan and George Bush. Since leaving government in 1993, he has been a columnist for Newsday; a contributor to the Fox News Channel and a regular on its Newswatch show.

William Anderson: Professor of Economics @ Frostburg State University, Senior Fellow at the Ludwig von Mises Institute, and frequent contributor to Lewrockwell.com

Daniel McCarthy: Literary Editor of the American Conservative. Mr. McCarthy has written for a variety of publications including Chronicles, Lewrockwell.com, and Modern Age.

Carl Horowitz: Director of the Organized Labor Accountability Project of the National Legal and Policy Center. Dr. Horowitz had served as a Washington correspondent for Investor's Business Daily, housing and urban affairs policy analyst with The Heritage Foundation, and professor of urban and regional planning at Virginia Polytechnic Institute. Click Here to see him discuss immigration on C-SPAN (2 hours into program, requires Real Player)